Stickies (FAQ)

Sunday, February 20, 2011

Anatomy of a push button tailcap

Things are often more complicated than they seem. The tailcap might seem straightforward, but it's been a challenge to get just right. There are lots of dimensional tolerances and lots of machining operations on this one little piece. I'm also integrating two products from two different manufacturers: the rubber tailcap boot and the actual switch.

Different stages of assembly from left to right:
cap, boot, o-rings/spacers, and switch
A couple of fiber washers and an o-ring are needed to give the switch the proper "stand-off" from the little rubber nub inside the switch boot. The correct clearance is +/- 0.015 inches. Thats about the thickness of five sheets of paper. I am surprised at how sensitive the clearance is.

Read on after the jump for some more detailed shots.



These are all of the parts (in order) that are required to make a simple tailcap. Let's put 'em together.


 First, in goes the rubber cap. I have a variety of colors on hand: orange, black, and glow in the dark green.


Next up is a little fiber washer that I'm using as a spacer. You can't buy o-rings in the exact dimension that I need.


Now in goes the actual o-ring. The rubber button actually seals the cap from water intrusion. The o-ring itself serves two purposes no related to creating a seal...which is the normal use for an o-ring. One, it acts as a spacer to give me clearance. Two, I've selected a relatively soft o-ring material so that it compresses slightly when I screw in the switch. This compression acts like a lock washer and should keep the switch from coming loose. If it does come loose, it's a simple matter to screw it back in by hand.


I suppose we are getting a little redundant but here is the second fiber spacer. I'm using two spacers for a specific engineering reason. If the o-ring was in direct contact with the rubber cap and the metal face of the switch, friction would make the o-ring twist and deform as the switch is screwed in. The fiber spacers reduce the friction and allow the components to be fastened together while maintaining even pressure on the o-ring.


Interestingly, the threads on the switch component are metric. All of the other threads on the light are standard national threads. I'm using a single point thread mill because it allows me to machine any thread pitch (within a range) with the same tool. I won't belabor the point but even selecting a threading tool is a series of compromises between thread form, machining speed, tool life, and number of tool slots in the tool changer.

Viola, a completed tailcap switch assembly! Simple right?

7 comments:

  1. jason this is great! how do i get one?
    - hh

    ReplyDelete
  2. What is the resistance on that switch? Also, have you considered using Mcclickies?
    -srfreddy

    ReplyDelete
  3. My Fluke meter reads about .2 Ohms for the McClicky switch and it bounces between .2 and .3 Ohms for the Romisen switch.

    I considered the McClicky and it is a much taller switch assembly. I'd have to add about 1/2 to the length of the light. I also think the contact spring rate is too heavy, but that's personal preference. I also prefer the all metal body on the Romisen switch.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great post about the clicky. How much current are these good for? I didn't think they could handle the 2.8A you put through them.
    -Ash

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Ash, you are right. I've switched over to "McClicky" switches because they do a better job with high current...and they are the gold standard for flashlight switches ;)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Very nice. That's my preference, but by your comments above I thought you had ruled them out. Now I know better.
    -Ash

    ReplyDelete
  7. Yep, there were a few challenges to overcome. In the end the light is about 1/4" longer. I also have to machine another part (retaining ring) to make it work. The McClicky is much more capable of handling almost 3 Amps of current though. I still think the Romisen is a nice switch for lower power applications, and it's easier to work with because it's metal and lower profile.

    Thanks for checking back!

    ReplyDelete